What they say:We guarantee you’ll rank #1 on Google in 30 days.
What’s really going on: Nobody controls Google’s free results, and Google’s own guide to hiring an SEO says so. Usually the “#1” is for a phrase nobody searches, or it’s a paid ad.
Red flags
A guarantee with a date on it.
They won’t say which searches you’ll rank for.
They’re vague about “secret” methods.
Do this instead: Ask for the three searches they’ll target and how many people make them each month.
What they say:Our AI SEO system gets your business recommended by ChatGPT and Google AI in 30 days.
What’s really going on: Nobody controls what AI tools say, and Google says there’s nothing special to do for its AI features beyond normal good SEO. It’s the old “#1 on Google” pitch with a new sticker.
Red flags
A guarantee about what an AI will say.
A secret “AI ranking system”.
Screenshots of one lucky answer as proof.
Do this instead: Make clear pages that answer real questions, keep your Google Business Profile complete, and get real reviews.
What they say:Our AI writes natural-sounding reviews in different styles. Nobody can tell.
What’s really going on: Fake reviews are fake whether a person or a robot writes them. The US FTC’s review rule covers AI-generated fakes and it has been enforcing it in 2026; the UK’s CMA has opened formal fake-review cases too.
Red flags
“Undetectable” or “human-sounding” in the pitch.
Reviews sold in bundles.
Reviews from accounts with no history.
Do this instead: Ask real customers on the day, with a QR code to your review link.
What they say:This is Google. Your Business Profile will be removed today unless you verify it with us for $99.
What’s really going on: Google doesn’t cold-call to charge you for keeping your listing. Business Profile is free. These are sales calls, or plain scams, using Google’s name.
Red flags
Urgency: “today”, “within the hour”.
A fee to “verify” or “protect” your listing.
They ask for a code Google sent you.
Do this instead: Hang up, open your profile yourself at google.com/business, and never share a verification code.
What they say:Get 50 five-star Google reviews delivered this week.
What’s really going on: Fake reviews break Google’s rules and, in many countries, consumer law. Google removes them, and can put a warning on your listing.
Red flags
Reviews sold in packs.
Reviewers with no photo and one review each.
“Undetectable” anywhere in the pitch.
Do this instead: Ask your happiest real customers, in person, the same day. Make it one tap with a direct review link.