Scam Watch

Pitches that land in your inbox every week. Each one crossed out, translated, and swapped for something that actually works.

SEO

“Guaranteed #1 on Google”

What they say: We guarantee you’ll rank #1 on Google in 30 days.

What’s really going on: Nobody controls Google’s free results, and Google’s own guide to hiring an SEO says so. Usually the “#1” is for a phrase nobody searches, or it’s a paid ad.

Red flags

  • A guarantee with a date on it.
  • They won’t say which searches you’ll rank for.
  • They’re vague about “secret” methods.

Do this instead: Ask for the three searches they’ll target and how many people make them each month.

SEO

“We’ll get you into ChatGPT answers, guaranteed”

What they say: Our AI SEO system gets your business recommended by ChatGPT and Google AI in 30 days.

What’s really going on: Nobody controls what AI tools say, and Google says there’s nothing special to do for its AI features beyond normal good SEO. It’s the old “#1 on Google” pitch with a new sticker.

Red flags

  • A guarantee about what an AI will say.
  • A secret “AI ranking system”.
  • Screenshots of one lucky answer as proof.

Do this instead: Make clear pages that answer real questions, keep your Google Business Profile complete, and get real reviews.

SEO

AI-written reviews, “undetectable”

What they say: Our AI writes natural-sounding reviews in different styles. Nobody can tell.

What’s really going on: Fake reviews are fake whether a person or a robot writes them. The US FTC’s review rule covers AI-generated fakes and it has been enforcing it in 2026; the UK’s CMA has opened formal fake-review cases too.

Red flags

  • “Undetectable” or “human-sounding” in the pitch.
  • Reviews sold in bundles.
  • Reviews from accounts with no history.

Do this instead: Ask real customers on the day, with a QR code to your review link.

SEO

“Your Google listing will be suspended” calls

What they say: This is Google. Your Business Profile will be removed today unless you verify it with us for $99.

What’s really going on: Google doesn’t cold-call to charge you for keeping your listing. Business Profile is free. These are sales calls, or plain scams, using Google’s name.

Red flags

  • Urgency: “today”, “within the hour”.
  • A fee to “verify” or “protect” your listing.
  • They ask for a code Google sent you.

Do this instead: Hang up, open your profile yourself at google.com/business, and never share a verification code.

SEO

What they say: Boost your Domain Authority with 1,000 high-quality backlinks.

What’s really going on: Cheap links in bulk come from junk sites built to sell links. At best Google ignores them. At worst they hurt you.

Red flags

  • A price per thousand links.
  • “High DA” promised, but no site names.
  • Delivered in a few days.

Do this instead: Earn a handful of real mentions: local press, suppliers, partners, happy customers with blogs.

SEO

Buy 5-star reviews

What they say: Get 50 five-star Google reviews delivered this week.

What’s really going on: Fake reviews break Google’s rules and, in many countries, consumer law. Google removes them, and can put a warning on your listing.

Red flags

  • Reviews sold in packs.
  • Reviewers with no photo and one review each.
  • “Undetectable” anywhere in the pitch.

Do this instead: Ask your happiest real customers, in person, the same day. Make it one tap with a direct review link.

PPC

“Set and forget” ads

What they say: We’ll set up your Google Ads once and they’ll run themselves.

What’s really going on: Unwatched ads keep spending on bad searches and tired creative. Someone has to check them weekly.

Red flags

  • A one-time setup fee and nothing after.
  • No list of searches you’ll show up for.
  • No way for you to see the account yourself.

Do this instead: Own the ad account in your name, and ask to see the search terms report every month.

PPC

Ad spend you can’t see

What they say: Just pay us $1,000 a month and we’ll handle the ad budget.

What’s really going on: When the agency owns the account, you can’t tell how much went to Google and how much they kept.

Red flags

  • The ad account is in their name.
  • One bundled monthly fee.
  • Reports as screenshots, never live access.

Do this instead: Pay Google directly from your card, and pay the agency a separate, visible fee.

Social

Buy 10k followers

What they say: Grow to 10,000 real, active followers in a week.

What’s really going on: Bought followers are bots or click farms. They never buy, and they drag down how many real people see your posts.

Red flags

  • Followers sold by the thousand.
  • “Real and active” in the pitch.
  • They ask for your password.

Do this instead: Post for the 100 people nearby who’d actually buy. A small real audience beats a big fake one.

Social

Engagement pods and like-for-like

What they say: Join our pod and every post gets 200 comments in the first hour.

What’s really going on: You get comments from other business owners who will never buy from you. Your numbers look busy, and your sales stay the same.

Red flags

  • Comments like “Great post!” from strangers.
  • Rules about commenting on everyone else’s posts.
  • Paid membership.

Do this instead: Reply properly to the people who already comment and message you. Those are the buyers.

Social

“We’ll make you go viral”

What they say: Our viral formula gets you a million views.

What’s really going on: Nobody can promise viral. And a million views from the wrong country or the wrong crowd sells nothing.

Red flags

  • Views promised, sales never mentioned.
  • Case studies with no business names.
  • Payment up front, results “in the algorithm’s hands”.

Do this instead: Judge any social media help by messages and orders, not views.

Social

Buy a list of 100,000 emails

What they say: Send your offer to 100,000 verified customers in your city.

What’s really going on: Those people never said yes to you. Most of it lands in spam, and in many places it breaks data protection law.

Red flags

  • A price per thousand contacts.
  • “Verified” or “targeted”, with no explanation of where they came from.
  • WhatsApp numbers sold in bulk.

Do this instead: Build your own list: a sign-up at the till, on receipts, on your site. Smaller, but they want to hear from you.

The big picture

The $999 secret marketing course

What they say: The system I used to make $100,000 a month. Only 10 seats left.

What’s really going on: The person often makes most of their money selling the course. The “secret” is usually free on YouTube.

Red flags

  • A countdown timer that resets.
  • Income screenshots instead of a syllabus.
  • No refunds, or refunds with conditions you can’t meet.

Do this instead: Learn one thing at a time from free sources, and try it on your own business this week.