---
title: "Ahrefs DR4, and why Domain Rating (and DA, Authority Score) are vanity metrics"
description: "Ahrefs is rolling out Domain Rating DR4. What changed, why scores move, and why DR, DA and Authority Score are vanity metrics Google doesn’t use."
url: https://dumbcmo.com/blog/ahrefs-dr4-vanity-domain-scores
category: "Getting found"
tags: ["news", "seo", "ahrefs", "domain rating", "moz", "semrush", "majestic", "backlinks", "vanity metrics"]
published: 2026-11-09
updated: 2026-11-09
reading_time: 16 min
author: "The DumbCMO"
---

# Ahrefs DR4, and why Domain Rating (and DA, Authority Score) are vanity metrics

> **TL;DR:** Ahrefs’ DR4 (UI on 1 Dec 2026) scores fewer sites, rates subdomains alone, and drops spam. DR, Moz DA, Semrush Authority Score and Majestic Trust Flow are each tool’s own estimate. Google doesn’t use them. Track clicks and sales, not a 0–100 sticker.

[Notebook](https://dumbcmo.com) › [Blog](https://dumbcmo.com/blog) › Getting found › Ahrefs DR4, and why Domain Rating (and DA, Authority Score) are vanity metrics

Ahrefs is updating [Domain Rating](https://ahrefs.com/blog/domain-rating-dr4/) again. The new version is called **DR4**. The Ahrefs UI gets it on **1 December 2026**. Your number may go up, down or disappear.

Before you panic, or before someone sells you a “recover your DR” package: Domain Rating is Ahrefs’ own score for the strength of a site’s **backlink profile** compared with other sites in *Ahrefs’* database. It is not Google. Moz has Domain Authority. Semrush has Authority Score. Majestic has Trust Flow. Same shape of product. Different maths. Google uses none of those stickers.

This note covers what Ahrefs changed in DR4, then the wider family of vanity scores: what they are, what Google has actually said, how they get gamed, and what to track instead.

## In normal-people words

## The short version

- **DR4 is Ahrefs’ fourth Domain Rating model.** It scores a smaller, “higher-quality” pool of domains, gives **subdomains their own scores**, and cuts spam scores hard. Ahrefs says it correlates better with Google ranking *positions across hosts and subdomains* than DR3.
- **UI rollout: 1 December 2026.** Preview is already available via API (`version=dr4`) and a [demo page](https://detailed.com/dr-v4/).
- **A drop is not a Google penalty.** Ahrefs says Domain Rating is relative and logarithmic. Your score can move when the pool or the formula changes, even if you did nothing.
- **DR, DA, Authority Score and Trust Flow are third-party estimates.** Each vendor builds them from its own crawl. Google Search Advocate John Mueller has said Google does **not** use scores from third-party SEO tools.
- **Useful for:** rough comparison *inside one tool*, spotting weird link patterns, triage for outreach. **Not useful as:** a KPI, a hiring reason, or a price list for guest posts.

> **The DumbCMO:** Google doesn’t use your agency’s favourite number. Ahrefs said that. Moz said that. Semrush said that. The invoice somehow forgot.

## What Ahrefs changed in DR4

Source for this whole section: Glen Allsopp’s Ahrefs post, [“Introducing a Preview of DR4”](https://ahrefs.com/blog/domain-rating-dr4/) (November 2026).

### Why they changed it

Ahrefs still calculates Domain Rating from **links**, not from content quality or domain age. They say they were clear about that before, and still are.

Two big product reasons for DR4:

1. **A smaller pool of domains that can affect the score.** They now put more weight on links from sites (and subdomains) they estimate have **organic search traffic**. Result: about **half** as many sites get a DR4 score as had a DR3 score. Fewer junk domains can push other sites’ numbers around.
2. **Subdomains get their own scores.** Under DR3, a thin GitHub Pages or Blogspot subdomain often inherited a sky-high score from the parent platform. Sorting link reports by DR made those look “strong”. DR4 scores the subdomain on links *to that subdomain*.

Ahrefs also says DR4 shows a **stronger correlation** with the number of top-3 and top-10 Google ranking positions across hosts and subdomains than DR3 (tested on 10 million hosts). On root domains alone, DR3 still correlated a bit higher with those position counts. Treat that as Ahrefs’ own study of Ahrefs’ metric, not as “Google uses DR”.

### How the calculation works now vs before

Ahrefs’ older public explainer still helps for the bones of DR ([backlink metrics lesson](https://ahrefs.com/academy/how-to-use-ahrefs/ahrefs-seo-metrics/backlink)):

- Scale **0–100**, **logarithmic**.
- Based on **unique referring domains** with at least one followed link (nofollow doesn’t help DR; extra links from the same domain don’t either).
- Higher-DR linking domains pass more “DR equity”.
- Sites that link out to many other domains pass less equity to each one.

What DR4 adds on top of that story, per the DR4 post:

- More weight for links from sites/subdomains with estimated organic traffic.
- Host-level scoring so subdomains no longer ride the parent’s DR (with a few older exceptions now rolled out much further).
- Spam-labelled domains (Ahrefs’ spam label, ML-based since January 2026) get hit hard in the new scores.

Ahrefs’ own help centre still says a low DR does **not** mean a site is spammy ([help article](https://help.ahrefs.com/en/articles/2408704-does-a-low-dr-mean-that-the-website-is-spammy)). New real sites can sit near zero. DR measures relative link strength in Ahrefs’ index, not legitimacy.

### What happens to scores (their numbers)

From the DR4 post:

**Subdomain examples (DR3 → DR4):**

- help.ahrefs.com: 91 → 75
- play.google.com: 100 → 96
- blogs.microsoft.com: 96 → 89
- finance.yahoo.com: 94 → 92
- blogs.oracle.com: 93 → 86
- insights.samsung.com: 92 → 74
- example Hostinger site subdomain: 92 → 1.9
- example Notion site subdomain: 92 → 0

**Spam:** domains Ahrefs labels as spam with DR3 between 30 and 70 saw the largest drops — median about **15–20 points**. Non-spam domains: median change close to zero across most DR3 ranges.

**Top 1,000 domains by Ahrefs’ organic traffic estimates** (via AhrefsTop):

- **64.3%** grew
- **15.8%** stayed the same
- **19.9%** decreased
- Among decreases: average drop **7.3** points, median **4**
- One big “loser” called out: `github.io` down **32** points (separate from github.com). A strong GitHub Pages subdomain like `facebook.github.io` can still sit high (they cite DR 86).

**Competitor example:** monday.com 91 → 90; Zoho −1 to 91; Teamwork stays 82; Airtable up slightly to 92.

### When it rolls out

- **Ahrefs UI: 1 December 2026**
- Preview now: Domain Rating API with `version=dr4` (free), and [detailed.com/dr-v4/](https://detailed.com/dr-v4/)
- For a short time after launch, DR3 stays comparable via the API

Ahrefs’ line if your score falls: *“A reduction in Domain Rating is not a judgment on the quality of your content or website.”* It’s about whether they see enough “quality” links in *their* model. And because DR is **relative** and **logarithmic**, moving 84 → 85 is harder than 54 → 55 — their words.

> **The DumbCMO:** A lower DR after an update is not a Google penalty. It’s Ahrefs changing its ruler. Don’t fire your writer over someone else’s maths.

## The vanity family: DR, DA, Authority Score, Trust Flow

Same shop window. Different shops.

**Third-party ‘authority’ scores at a glance**

| Metric | Who makes it | Scale | Roughly based on | Does Google use it? |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Domain Rating (DR) | Ahrefs | 0–100, logarithmic | Strength of the site’s backlink profile vs other sites in Ahrefs’ index | No |
| Authority Score | Semrush | 0–100 (relative) | Link power, estimated organic traffic, spam / natural-profile signals | No |
| Domain Authority (DA) · Page Authority | Moz | 1–100 (relative) | ML model on Link Explorer backlink data; PA is page-level | No |
| Trust Flow · Citation Flow | Majestic | 0–100, logarithmic | CF ≈ link ‘power’ through the network; TF ≈ closeness to a human-trusted seed set | No |

Sources for that table: [Ahrefs backlink metrics](https://ahrefs.com/academy/how-to-use-ahrefs/ahrefs-seo-metrics/backlink), [Semrush Authority Score explainer](https://www.semrush.com/blog/semrush-authority-score-explained/), Semrush’s note that higher scores get progressively harder ([enterprise FAQ](https://enterprise.semrush.com/data-products/authority-and-backlink-benchmarking/)), [Moz Domain Authority](https://moz.com/learn/seo/domain-authority), [Majestic Flow Metrics](https://majestic.com/flow-metric-scores).

**Moz also sells Brand Authority™**, listed next to DA and PA on Moz’s DA page as a third “authority” score about brand strength / salience. Same rule: Moz’s number, not Google’s. I couldn’t pull a full public calculation write-up for Brand Authority for this note, so treat it as “another Moz sticker” until you’ve read Moz’s own page.

### They disagree with each other (on purpose)

Ahrefs says it plainly: backlink and referring-domain counts “will fairly go up and down” differently across tools, “since we all crawl the web differently.”

So if Ahrefs says DR 42, Moz says DA 28 and Semrush says Authority Score 35 for the same shop, nobody is “wrong”. They’re grading different homework. **Never** average them. Pick one tool for comparisons, or ignore the stickers and look at the actual linking sites.

I am not inventing a multi-tool scorecard for one live domain here. The DR4 post’s own DR3-vs-DR4 table is enough proof that even *one* vendor’s number jumps when the formula changes.

## What Google has actually said

### Third-party tool scores

In an [#AskGooglebot video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AiAxHYcEDiM) (covered by [Search Engine Land](https://searchengineland.com/google-search-seo-tools-scores-430771) and [Search Engine Journal](https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-we-dont-use-third-party-seo-tool-scores-for-rankings/493956/), August 2023), Google Search Advocate **John Mueller** said:

> “No, Google does not use scores from third-party SEO tools or services. It doesn’t matter whether it’s about a website’s authority or a rating about spamminess, Google doesn’t use these scores at all.”

And: transparently calculated scores *can* still help you spot issues or estimate standing — if you know how the score is made. His closer, as SEJ quotes it: Google doesn’t use those scores for search, “that doesn’t mean that they’re all useless.”

### “Domain authority” as a Google signal

**Gary Illyes** (then at Google) on X/Twitter, 27 October 2016, widely quoted:

> “we don’t really have ‘overall domain authority’. A text link with anchor text is better though”

At SMX West, answering whether Google keeps a Domain Authority-style metric, Illyes said Google feels that approach doesn’t really work — e.g. user blogs on blogspot.com shouldn’t inherit the main domain’s authority; ranking is page-specific. Mariya Moeva added there’s no similar signal for folders either. (Industry write-up of that Q&A: [SEO Rank Video Blog](http://seorankvideo.blogspot.com/2017/03/39-questions-with-google-at-smx-west.html).)

**Paul Haahr** (Google search quality engineer), to Search Engine Land: Google has “no one signal that we’ll say, ‘This is authority.’” Authority is assessed with a bunch of things, primarily **per page**, not as one domain score that gifts every URL on a big host ([SEL, 2016](https://searchengineland.com/google-authority-metric-274231)).

### The 2024 `siteAuthority` leak — handle it honestly

Leaked Google Content Warehouse API docs include a field called `siteAuthority` on compressed quality signals, described as converted from `quality_nsr.SiteAuthority` and “applied in Qstar” ([hexdocs copy of the attribute list](https://google-api-content-warehouse.hexdocs.pm/0.4.0/GoogleApi.ContentWarehouse.V1.Model.CompressedQualitySignals.html)).

What that proves: Google’s systems have an internal attribute with that name.

What it does **not** prove:

- That it’s Moz DA, Ahrefs DR or Semrush Authority Score (it isn’t; those are vendor products).
- How it’s calculated, how heavy it is, or that you can buy a guest post to move it.
- That Mueller and Illyes were “lying” about third-party scores. Third-party stickers and an internal Google attribute can both exist. Only one of those is on your Ahrefs dashboard.

If an agency waves the leak as “see, domain authority is real, buy our DR package,” that’s a category error. Different animals.

## How these scores get gamed (why “vanity”)

Vanity metric, in plain words: a number that looks impressive in a slide and is easy to chase without helping the business.

How the chase usually goes:

1. **Guest posts priced by DR or DA.** “DR 70 site, $400.” The seller is pricing Ahrefs’ or Moz’s sticker, not your customers.
2. **Link schemes built to inflate the sticker.** Networks of sites that exist to pass link equity to each other. Google’s own [link spam guidance](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies#link-spam) is the rulebook; the sticker is the sales decoy.
3. **PBNs (private blog networks).** Same idea, more deliberate. You buy or rent a fake neighbourhood of sites. The score may climb. The risk sits with you.
4. **Reporting theatre.** Monthly deck opens with “DR 34 → 41”. Search Console clicks on money queries are on slide 11, in 8-point type.

Ahrefs, Moz and Semrush all warn — in their own docs — that the score is **relative**. Moz’s classic example: if Facebook suddenly gained a billion new links, *other* sites’ DA could drop relative to Facebook even if those other sites did nothing. Ahrefs says the same shape of thing for DR4: your number can move when the pool or the model changes.

So you can “lose” points while your real traffic is fine. Or “gain” points from links that never send a human.

## The chai stall version

There’s a board outside the stall that rates every chai shop from 0 to 100, drawn by three different tourists with three different notebooks.

One tourist only counts how many other stalls pointed a finger at you. Another counts fingers *and* guesses footfall. A third only trusts stalls that a human once called “good”.

None of them is the municipal health inspector. **None of them is your till.**

## What these scores are actually useful for

Keep the useful jobs. Throw away the worship.

- **Rough comparison inside one tool.** Your site vs three competitors in Ahrefs *or* Moz *or* Semrush — not mixed.
- **Link-quality outliers.** A referring domain with a sky-high sticker and zero real traffic (or Ahrefs’ spam label) deserves a human look.
- **Outreach triage.** When you have 200 possible sites to ask for a mention, a score can help you sort the pile. Then you still open the site.
- **Sanity after a vendor update.** When DR4 lands, check your competitors too, like Ahrefs suggests. If everyone in your niche moved, your deck needs context.

What they’re **not**:

- A Google ranking factor you can buy.
- Proof your content is good or bad.
- A reason to hire (or fire) an SEO person by themselves.
- A KPI next to revenue.

> **The DumbCMO:** “We got you to DR 50” is a sales line. Ask for Search Console clicks on the queries that pay the bills.

## What to track instead

Boring. Useful.

1. **Google Search Console** — clicks and impressions on the queries that lead to money (branded and non-branded). Our [regex cheatsheet](/blog/regex-cheatsheet-for-marketers) helps you split them.
2. **Conversions** — form fills, calls, orders. If you don’t know what a customer costs, read [CAC and LTV](/blog/cac-and-ltv-explained).
3. **Referral traffic from links** — in your analytics, not in a link tool’s fantasy of “link equity”.
4. **Relevant real sites mentioning you** — suppliers, local press, industry blogs, happy customers. One link from a site your buyers read beats twenty from a DR 60 farm.
5. **For AI answers** — whether you get cited or mentioned, using first-party tools where they exist (Bing’s [AI Performance / Topics Portfolio](/blog/bing-topics-portfolio-ai-performance), and whatever OpenAI ships for ChatGPT). Covered more in [SEO in the age of AI answers](/blog/seo-in-the-age-of-ai-answers).

Links still matter. Google has never said “ignore links”. It has said, repeatedly, that **Moz’s DA / Ahrefs’ DR / Semrush’s sticker** are not how it ranks you. Chase the link a human would trust. Let the sticker move however it moves.

**When someone brings up DR or DA**

- **If** Your DR dropped on 1 Dec and nothing else changed **→ then** Check competitors in Ahrefs. Read the DR4 post. Update the footnote in your report. Do not rewrite your content strategy overnight.
- **If** An agency’s proposal leads with ‘we’ll raise your DA/DR’ **→ then** Ask for Search Console clicks, conversions and example links from real relevant sites. If they can’t show that, you’re buying a sticker.
- **If** A guest-post rate card is priced only by DR **→ then** Ask who reads that site. Open it. If it’s a hollow English-language shell with spun posts, walk.
- **If** Someone cites the Google siteAuthority leak as proof you must buy links **→ then** The leak shows an internal field name. It does not sell guest posts. Demand the difference.
- **If** You use DR inside Ahrefs to sort outreach prospects **→ then** Fine. Then open the top 20 sites. Score is a sort key, not a purchase order.

## Do this today

- [ ] Open the Ahrefs DR4 preview (API or the demo page) for your domain and two competitors. Note DR3 vs DR4. Screenshot it for December.
- [ ] Open Search Console. Write down last 28 days’ clicks on your top non-brand queries. That’s your real baseline.
- [ ] If an agency report leads with DA/DR, ask them to add GSC clicks and conversions on the first page next month.
- [ ] Audit any “DR 50+ guest post” purchases from the last year. Open five of those sites. Keep a note on whether a human would trust them.
- [ ] Pick one relevant site your customers already read. Pitch one useful piece or data point. One real mention beats a sticker bump.

## Not-so-frequently asked questions

### Is Domain Rating a Google ranking factor?

No. It’s Ahrefs’ metric. John Mueller has said Google does not use scores from third-party SEO tools.

### My DR will drop on 1 December. Am I in trouble with Google?

Not because of DR4. Ahrefs is changing its model. Compare competitors, check Search Console, and keep publishing useful pages.

### Should I switch from Moz DA to Ahrefs DR?

Only if you already live in that tool. Don’t run both as KPIs. One ruler for comparisons is enough; Google is still not that ruler.

### What about Google’s siteAuthority from the API leak?

It’s an internal attribute name in leaked docs. It is not DR or DA, and the docs don’t give you a score you can buy your way up.

### Are backlinks pointless then?

No. Links from real, relevant sites still help people and search engines discover you. Buying links to juice a third-party score is the pointless part. See also [scam watch on cheap backlink packages](/scam-watch#backlink-packages).

### Is a high DR site always a good place to get a link?

No. Ahrefs itself says DR isn’t a spam or quality verdict. Open the site. Check traffic, relevance and whether you’d send your mum there.

## Things your agency won’t say

- “Guaranteed DA 40 in 90 days” is bullsh#t. They don’t control Moz’s model, and Moz doesn’t control Google.
- Pricing guest posts by DR alone is selling you a screenshot. Ask who the readers are.
- The adult report opens with Search Console clicks and sales, and puts DR in a footnote when an update makes it noisy.

## Jargon Jail

**Locked up: “Vanity metric”**

A number that looks good in a meeting and is easy to move without helping the business. **DR, DA and Authority Score become vanity metrics when you chase the sticker instead of clicks, customers and real relevant links.**

## The calm takeaway

DR4 is a real product update from Ahrefs: fewer scored sites, honest subdomain scores, spam cut down, UI on 1 December 2026. Worth knowing if you live in Ahrefs.

It is still a **vendor score**. So are Moz DA, Semrush Authority Score and Majestic Trust Flow. Google has said, out loud, that it doesn’t use those third-party scores. An internal `siteAuthority` field in a leak doesn’t turn your agency’s DR package into a ranking lever.

Use the stickers as a rough sort. Run the business on Search Console, conversions and mentions on sites humans actually read.

## Where to go next

- SEO basics: [What is SEO?](/blog/what-is-seo)
- AI answers vs rankings: [Does SEO still matter now that Google answers with AI?](/blog/seo-in-the-age-of-ai-answers)
- Splitting brand traffic in Search Console: [Regex cheatsheet for marketers](/blog/regex-cheatsheet-for-marketers)
- Cheap link packages: [Scam watch](/scam-watch#backlink-packages)
- How long the boring work takes: [How long does SEO take?](/blog/how-long-does-seo-take)

## Sources

1. Glen Allsopp / Ahrefs, [“Introducing a Preview of DR4: Our New Domain Rating Model for Scoring Backlink Profiles”](https://ahrefs.com/blog/domain-rating-dr4/), November 2026 — DR4 changes, subdomain table, correlation study, spam drops, top-1,000 traffic domains, Dec 1 UI rollout, relative/logarithmic reminder.
2. Ahrefs Academy, [“Backlink metrics”](https://ahrefs.com/academy/how-to-use-ahrefs/ahrefs-seo-metrics/backlink) — DR/UR logarithmic 0–100, referring-domain rules, different crawlers disagree.
3. Ahrefs Help, [“Does a low DR mean that the website is spammy?”](https://help.ahrefs.com/en/articles/2408704-does-a-low-dr-mean-that-the-website-is-spammy).
4. John Mueller / Google Search Central, [#AskGooglebot: Does Google Search use SEO scores?](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AiAxHYcEDiM); write-ups: [Search Engine Land](https://searchengineland.com/google-search-seo-tools-scores-430771), [Search Engine Journal](https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-we-dont-use-third-party-seo-tool-scores-for-rankings/493956/) (Aug 2023).
5. Gary Illyes on X/Twitter, 27 Oct 2016 — “we don’t really have ‘overall domain authority’…” (widely quoted; see contemporaneous coverage such as [searchengines.guru](https://searchengines.guru/ru/news/36504)).
6. SMX West Google Q&A write-up, [“39 questions with Google”](http://seorankvideo.blogspot.com/2017/03/39-questions-with-google-at-smx-west.html) — Illyes on Domain Authority-style metrics; Moeva on folders.
7. Search Engine Land, [“How Google measures the authority of web pages”](https://searchengineland.com/google-authority-metric-274231) — Paul Haahr on no single authority signal; page-level assessment.
8. Google Content Warehouse API docs (leaked schema mirror), [`siteAuthority` on CompressedQualitySignals](https://google-api-content-warehouse.hexdocs.pm/0.4.0/GoogleApi.ContentWarehouse.V1.Model.CompressedQualitySignals.html).
9. Moz, [“Domain Authority: What is it and how is it calculated”](https://moz.com/learn/seo/domain-authority) — DA 1–100, relative, not a Google factor; Facebook relative-drop example; Brand Authority named alongside DA/PA.
10. Semrush, [“What Is Semrush’s Authority Score?”](https://www.semrush.com/blog/semrush-authority-score-explained/) and [Authority Score enterprise FAQ](https://enterprise.semrush.com/data-products/authority-and-backlink-benchmarking/) — links + estimated traffic + spam signals; not Google’s; higher scores harder.
11. Majestic, [Flow Metric Scores](https://majestic.com/flow-metric-scores) and [glossary](https://majestic.com/help/glossary/) — Trust Flow / Citation Flow 0–100, logarithmic Flow Metrics.
12. Google Search, [Link spam policies](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies#link-spam).

## Related notes

- [Google is testing Search without AI Mode](https://dumbcmo.com/blog/google-testing-search-without-ai-mode): Since late October, a few people have seen Google with no AI Mode button, and on 13 Nov with no AI Mode tab or “Ask anything” box. Google hasn’t commented. It’s a test, not a shutdown: the AI summary box still shows. Don’t change your SEO for it. Keep being the business AI answers mention.
- [Google November 2026 core update: what to do](https://dumbcmo.com/blog/google-november-2026-core-update): Google released the November 2026 core update on 10 Nov 2026. It is global, all languages, and may take up to 2 weeks, so it could end around 24 Nov, three days before Black Friday. Google named no targets. Save a baseline week now, don’t rebuild pages mid-rollout, and judge it after it ends.
- [ChatGPT for businesses is official: claim your listing, then wait](https://dumbcmo.com/blog/chatgpt-for-businesses-business-hub): OpenAI launched Businesses in ChatGPT in beta on 10 Nov 2026. Claim a listing, keep your info current, and see mentions and website clicks. Business Agents are a separate, US-only feature. I tried the hub, added our business, and hit a waitlist. Claiming does not make ChatGPT recommend you more.

---

From [DumbCMO](https://dumbcmo.com): The marketing notes you were too embarrassed to take.
